[mabry1985]

Pins every plugin in the bundle to its newest release tag as of 2026-10-24, for the fleet roll onto protoAgent 0.215.0. This replaces the stale bump-pins-* PRs. verified_against is left as it is, because this pin set hasn't been re-verified against 0.215.0.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

[protoreview]

QA panel review — PASS

code-review · head 694f33570171 · formal

Low-risk change: manifest pin bumps without corresponding doc updates. The one thing to fix before merge is the README pin list (line 26), which still shows the pre-bump versions and will mislead anyone checking compatibility. The YAML comment staleness is a valid hygiene point but can follow up. The panel unanimously flagged both items across multiple review angles; verification confirmed both against the PR head with no disagreement. No coverage gaps — the diff is small and fully read.

Findings

	Severity	Location	Finding	Verified
🟡	minor	README.md:26	README still lists the pre-bump pin set (project_board v0.65.0, github v0.9.1) and the core floor derived from v0.65.0, contradicting the manifest's new pins (…	confirmed
⚪	nit	protoagent.bundle.yaml:98	The CORE FLOOR comment still cites projectBoard v0.65.0's min_protoagent_version, but the pin is now v0.72.0; the attribution is stale and could mislead a read…	confirmed

findings JSON (machine-readable)

[
  {
    "file": "README.md",
    "line": 26,
    "severity": "minor",
    "category": "conventions",
    "claim": "README still lists the pre-bump pin set (project_board v0.65.0, github v0.9.1) and the core floor derived from v0.65.0, contradicting the manifest's new pins (v0.72.0 / v0.9.3). Flagged by both cross-file and conventions review.",
    "evidence": "**Core floor: protoAgent \u2265 0.185.0** \u2014 projectBoard v0.65.0's\n`min_protoagent_version`. Pins: project_board v0.65.0, agent_browser v0.6.4,\ngithub v0.9.1 (verified against core 0.200.0).",
    "verdict": "confirmed",
    "note": "README at PR head still says v0.65.0/v0.9.1; manifest at same head says v0.72.0/v0.9.3. Diff confirms manifest was bumped, README untouched."
  },
  {
    "file": "protoagent.bundle.yaml",
    "line": 98,
    "severity": "nit",
    "category": "conventions",
    "claim": "The CORE FLOOR comment still cites projectBoard v0.65.0's min_protoagent_version, but the pin is now v0.72.0; the attribution is stale and could mislead a reader about which pin set the floor was derived from. Flagged by correctness, cross-file, and conventions review.",
    "evidence": "# CORE FLOOR: protoAgent >= 0.185.0 \u2014 projectBoard v0.65.0's min_protoagent_version.",
    "verdict": "confirmed",
    "note": "Comment at PR head still says 'projectBoard v0.65.0's min_protoagent_version' while the pin line below it is now ref: v0.72.0. Diff shows pin changed, comment not."
  }
]

---

1 finding(s) excluded from the verdict by in-diff confinement (file not among this PR's changed paths):

• README.md (minor) — README still lists the pre-bump pin set (project_board v0.65.0, github v0.9.1) and the core floor derived from v0.65.0, contradicting the manifest's new pins (v

[protoreview]

Promoting the PASS verdict for head 694f33570171: all checks terminal-green, zero unresolved review threads. (approve-on-green)

Open findings carried by this approval — non-blocking, but they did not go away:

• minor README.md:26 — README still lists the pre-bump pin set (project_board v0.65.0, github v0.9.1) and the core floor derived from v0.65.0, contradicting the manifest's new pins (v0.72.0 / v0.9.3). Flagged by both cross-
• nit protoagent.bundle.yaml:98 — The CORE FLOOR comment still cites projectBoard v0.65.0's min_protoagent_version, but the pin is now v0.72.0; the attribution is stale and could mislead a reader about which pin set the floor was deri

Approving a WARN does not resolve its findings (issue #22).