You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
[FEA] - stop defaulting to 4K when multiple "versions" of same media exist #610
Dealing with versions and preventing access to 4K content from the WAN are the primary reasons most Jellyfin users will create a separate library for 4K movies.
Currently, by default, Wholphin chooses the source with the highest resolution.
@DrHurt, is the primary use case just for bandwidth restrictions? If so, maybe a solution would be for the default choice to also consider the max bandwidth settings. In other words, choose the source with the highest resolution under the max bandwidth. What do you think?
I'm not sure if the server playback info API automatically switches versions to respect the max bandwidth or not, I'll have to test.
FWIW, I manage my 4K content as @NeuroDawg suggests, separate Movie & 4k Movie libraries. This simplifies sharing as well.
changed the title [-][BUG] - stop defaulting to 4K when multiple "versions" of same media exist[/-][+][FEA] - stop defaulting to 4K when multiple "versions" of same media exist[/+]on Jan 7, 2026
4K & especially Blu-ray remuxes use an awful lot of data so I prefer 1080p unless we’re having a weekend movie night then I play the remuxes off my remote server.
Max bandwidth would be an interesting approach and certainly one I can use to avoid defaulting to massive bluray remuxes!
I was hoping for a “prefer HD over 4K” option but your suggestion will suit me as well (but might be more confusing for less savvy users)
Can't we just have the popup for what version to play when we click the play button? It's available via the ellipses menu but why there? It makes way more sense to popup when you hit play. Also, would be great if there was an option for the trailer button to do the opposite and ONLY play the local version if available.
Can't we just have the popup for what version to play when we click the play button? It's available via the ellipses menu but why there? It makes way more sense to popup when you hit play. Also, would be great if there was an option for the trailer button to do the opposite and ONLY play the local version if available.
This would still be annoying and it wouldn't work when you're auto playing episodes either.
The core issue is that Wholphin apparently prefers the highest-resolution version, even when Jellyfin has another version set as the primary one. For example, I deliberately have 480p as the primary version of some TV episodes and 1080p as the alternative, but Wholphin still starts the 1080p version automatically.
As I said earlier, a popup on every play action wouldn't really solve this, especially for TV shows where episodes are auto-playing.
Wouldn't the cleaner solution be to remember the user's version choice, similar to how Wholphin already remembers audio and subtitle selections? If I select 480p instead of 1080p, that preference could carry over to subsequent episodes with the same available versions. This would require no additional interaction during normal playback and would work with autoplay as well.
Wouldn't the cleaner solution be to remember the user's version choice, similar to how Wholphin already remembers audio and subtitle selections?
I think this is the solution. For movies, this happens already. For TV shows, I was thinking of using a similar approach as in #1802 to choose the best match for future episodes.
Activity
DrHurt commentedon Jan 1, 2026
Sorry this is probably more an enhancement / feature request than a bug.
It would be very helpful though to have an option as I have limited data allowance.
NeuroDawg commentedon Jan 1, 2026
Dealing with versions and preventing access to 4K content from the WAN are the primary reasons most Jellyfin users will create a separate library for 4K movies.
DrHurt commentedon Jan 1, 2026
Well yeah but that's a brute force fix.
I think there should be an option for default "version" in the app.
damontecres commentedon Jan 7, 2026
Currently, by default, Wholphin chooses the source with the highest resolution.
@DrHurt, is the primary use case just for bandwidth restrictions? If so, maybe a solution would be for the default choice to also consider the max bandwidth settings. In other words, choose the source with the highest resolution under the max bandwidth. What do you think?
I'm not sure if the server playback info API automatically switches versions to respect the max bandwidth or not, I'll have to test.
FWIW, I manage my 4K content as @NeuroDawg suggests, separate Movie & 4k Movie libraries. This simplifies sharing as well.
[-][BUG] - stop defaulting to 4K when multiple "versions" of same media exist[/-][+][FEA] - stop defaulting to 4K when multiple "versions" of same media exist[/+]DrHurt commentedon Jan 7, 2026
My personal use case is monthly internet quota.
4K & especially Blu-ray remuxes use an awful lot of data so I prefer 1080p unless we’re having a weekend movie night then I play the remuxes off my remote server.
Max bandwidth would be an interesting approach and certainly one I can use to avoid defaulting to massive bluray remuxes!
I was hoping for a “prefer HD over 4K” option but your suggestion will suit me as well (but might be more confusing for less savvy users)
Mobeeuz commentedon Apr 16, 2026
Can't we just have the popup for what version to play when we click the play button? It's available via the ellipses menu but why there? It makes way more sense to popup when you hit play. Also, would be great if there was an option for the trailer button to do the opposite and ONLY play the local version if available.
j4n0nym0u5 commentedon Sep 16, 2026
This would still be annoying and it wouldn't work when you're auto playing episodes either.
j4n0nym0u5 commentedon Sep 16, 2026
The core issue is that Wholphin apparently prefers the highest-resolution version, even when Jellyfin has another version set as the primary one. For example, I deliberately have 480p as the primary version of some TV episodes and 1080p as the alternative, but Wholphin still starts the 1080p version automatically.
As I said earlier, a popup on every play action wouldn't really solve this, especially for TV shows where episodes are auto-playing.
Wouldn't the cleaner solution be to remember the user's version choice, similar to how Wholphin already remembers audio and subtitle selections? If I select 480p instead of 1080p, that preference could carry over to subsequent episodes with the same available versions. This would require no additional interaction during normal playback and would work with autoplay as well.
Mobeeuz commentedon Sep 16, 2026
Retaining resolution during sessions would be the solution, which you've (mostly) answered for yourself.
noamsiegel commentedon Nov 11, 2026
Any update on this?
Happy to make a PR, but not sure if the maintainers/devs are swamped reviewing AI slop.
damontecres commentedon Nov 12, 2026
I think this is the solution. For movies, this happens already. For TV shows, I was thinking of using a similar approach as in #1802 to choose the best match for future episodes.
Let me add this to my TODO.