PCE assigns binary variables to signs of same-axis Pauli correlations on a compressed register. It follows the encoding, MaxCut loss and final classical improvement step of Sciorilli et al., Towards large-scale quantum optimization solvers with few qubits, Nature Communications 16, 476 (2025). The ansatz and classical optimizer are configurable; choosing another circuit does not reproduce the paper's particular benchmark setup.
For (N) variables, order (r), and axis set (A), QASP chooses the smallest
(n) with (|A|\binom{n}{r}\geq N), unless n_qubits is specified. Correlations
are assigned in axis order, then lexicographic wire combinations. The defaults
are correlation_order=2 and paulis="XYZ".
Let (c_i=\langle P_i\rangle), (s_i=\tanh(\alpha c_i)), and
(R=(N^{-1}\sum_i s_i^2)^2). For QUBO.maxcut, each undirected edge counted
once, the loss is exactly
[ L=\sum_{(i,j)\in E}w_{ij}s_i s_j+\beta\nu R. ]
regularization is (\beta), default 0.5. For a connected graph with positive
weights, (\nu=w(G)/2+w(T_{\min})/4). Unweighted graphs therefore use
(\nu=|E|/2+(N-1)/4). Disconnected graphs use the minimum spanning forest,
equivalently summing this scale over connected components; isolated vertices
contribute zero. regularization_scale optionally overrides (\nu), including
zero. The default alpha is (n^{\lfloor r/2\rfloor}); it can be tuned explicitly.
All three numerical hyperparameters must be finite, with positive alpha and
nonnegative regularization and scale.
For a general QUBO with Ising energy (E(s)=c+\sum h_i s_i+\sum J_{ij}s_i s_j),
the data term is (2(E(s)-c)). The default scale uses the positive part of
weights (2J_{ij}) and adds (\sum_i|h_i|). This preserves scaling under a
positive rescaling of the QUBO. The positive-part convention for signed edges
follows the authors' reference implementation;
the field term is a QASP extension, not a MaxCut bound for arbitrary QUBOs.
Use regularization_scale when a problem-specific scale is appropriate.
loss_tensor(parameters) differentiates the entire nonlinear function of
correlators. In particular, parameter-shift differentiates the underlying
expectations and applies the classical chain rule; shifting the already
nonlinear loss as if it were one expectation would be incorrect.
from qasp import Normal, PCE, QUBO, draw_pce
problem = QUBO.maxcut(3, [(0, 1, 1.0), (1, 2, 2.0), (0, 2, 3.0)])
config = {
"correlation_order": 2,
"regularization": 0.5,
"init": Normal(0, 0.3),
"backend": "torch",
"device": "default.qubit",
"diff_method": "backprop",
"seed": 7,
}
model = PCE(problem, **config)
result = model.solve(
optimizer="Adam",
optimizer_options={"max_steps": 80, "lr": 0.03},
)
print("Encoding:", model.pauli_labels)
print("Regularizer scale:", model.regularization_scale)
print("Raw candidate:", result.metadata["raw_bitstring"], result.metadata["raw_energy"])
print("Improved candidate:", result.bitstring, result.energy)
print("Training loss:", result.objective)
fig, ax = draw_pce(model, parameters=result, output="matplotlib")
draw_pce(model, parameters=result, output="tikz", return_tex=False)solve(postprocess=True) makes one sequential sweep, visiting variables in
index order and retaining only strictly improving flips. This is outside
autodiff and is not repeated until convergence. It takes (O(N+|E|)) operations
after adjacency construction. result.energy is the original QUBO energy
of the improved candidate; for MaxCut its negative is the cut weight.
result.objective remains the optimized PCE loss, not a cut value.
decode(parameters) always returns the raw candidate, with exact zero
correlations mapped to bit zero. solve(postprocess=False) returns this raw
candidate as the final result. improve_bitstring(bits) exposes the same sweep
for any candidate of this QUBO, including a QAOA result. Metadata always retains
the raw candidate, its energy, the readout correlations, and whether the sweep
was requested. With finite shots, the raw candidate and recorded correlations
come from the same readout.
| Simulator | PCE circuit | Differentiation |
|---|---|---|
default.qubit |
General supported ansatz | backprop or adjoint |
lightning.qubit |
General supported ansatz | adjoint |
PauliPropagationSimulator |
Supported noncommuting gates | Torch backprop; {"k": None, "prune": False} for exact checks |
default.tensor, method mps or tn |
General supported ansatz | Explicit parameter-shift; requires Quimb |
IQPSimulator, tn / van_den_nest / auto |
Compatible commuting circuit and readout | Torch backprop |
PCE's default Y/Z/ZZ circuit is noncommuting and is not a VN circuit. For IQP
execution, supply commuting X/XX/XXX rotations and paulis="Z", or another
supported IQP construction. Restricting the axis set changes the encoding
capacity and potentially the register size. Backend equivalence tests must
compare the same circuit, encoding and parameters.
VN enumeration gives an exact small-system reference. Sampled VN differentiates the empirical nonlinear loss; this need not be an unbiased estimate of the exact nonlinear loss or its gradient. Use a fixed sample bank for finite difference checks. Finite-shot measurements have the analogous issue. Approximate MPS truncation and Pauli pruning also change values and gradients.
In a TikZ diagram, slash-separated meter labels such as X/Y/Z denote alternative
readout settings on separate circuit preparations, not simultaneous measurements
in incompatible bases. pauli_labels lists the actual correlation observables.
For double-precision Torch/Lightning comparisons, set
torch.set_default_dtype(torch.float64) before constructing the models, in
addition to supplying float64 parameters. PennyLane's conversion of scalar
Lightning results uses Torch's default dtype.
Run the comparison tutorial for unweighted and weighted MaxCut graphs, exact small-instance optima, several initializations, raw and improved cuts, training curves, timings and circuit drawings. Both methods receive the same optimizer-step budget and the same optional classical sweep. Their ansatz sizes, output rules and losses differ; these small experiments are not evidence of a general performance advantage.