Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
28 lines (23 loc) · 2.88 KB

ui_ux_audit_report.md

File metadata and controls

28 lines (23 loc) · 2.88 KB

PetFolio UI/UX Audit Report

Date: 2026-05-30 Target Emulator: emulator-5554 Evaluation Scope: flutter-ui-ux Skill Guidelines

Phase 1: Shell Navigation & Layout Stability

  • Execution Path: Navigated sequentially through the bottom navigation anchors (Pets, Care, Social, Match, Market).
  • Findings: The application shell (AppHeader and AppShell) maintained stable constraints during transitions between tabs. No visual layout shifting or overflow exceptions were observed when swapping the root index.

Phase 2: Accessibility & Overflow Stress Test

  • Execution Path: Tapped the active pet switcher pill to expose the bottom sheet and navigated to the /pets/manage route. Evaluated the "Add another pet" button (manage_pets_add_button) and active pet header pill.
  • Findings & Violations:
    • Accessibility Violation: The "Add another pet" button (manage_pets_add_button) is implemented using a raw GestureDetector that completely lacks a Semantics wrapper. This violates the flutter-ui-ux accessibility constraints. Screen readers will not announce this action correctly.
      • Widget Node: Type: GestureDetector, Key: "manage_pets_add_button", bounds: {"x":20.0,"y":339.1,"width":371.4,"height":74.0}
    • Responsive Design: The active pet header pill sized text appropriately without abrupt truncation. Constraints gracefully handle rendering inside the widget.

Phase 3: Component State & Cart Micro-interactions

  • Execution Path: Navigated to the Care tab and toggled a pending care task (e.g. Evening Feeding). Navigated to the Marketplace tab, tapped the cart icon, and subsequently dismissed it via the system back route.
  • Findings:
    • Optimistic UI: State updates instantly when marking a care task as complete.
    • Micro-interactions: The cart bottom sheet slides smoothly into view and dismisses properly without visual clipping. Note: The market_action_cart key and the care task keys (e.g., care_task_check_<id>) were not explicitly exposed as standard String ValueKeys in the DOM tree in some cases, requiring fallback to coordinate-based interactions.

Phase 4: Discovery Deck Animation (Performance)

  • Execution Path: Navigated to the Matching tab to evaluate swipe gestures on discovery candidates. Triggered swipe actions using the floating controls (✕ and 🐾).
  • Findings:
    • Animation & State: Swipe transitions executed smoothly without observable rendering hitches or frame drops. The card removal and subsequent candidate replacement were visually fluid.
    • Accessibility Note: The floating control buttons (✕, ⭐, 🐾, ↺) were present on screen but their respective semantic keys (match_action_pass, match_action_like) were missing from the interactive elements tree. Wrapping them with Semantics and assigning the requested keys is recommended to ensure proper accessibility support.